In the modern automotive landscape, service marketing isn’t just a box to check — it’s a strategic growth engine. With shrinking margins in vehicle sales and intensifying competition for customer loyalty, dealers must rely on their fixed operations to generate consistent revenue. But simply having a service department isn’t enough — you need a partner who can fill your bays, increase RO value, and improve long-term retention through intelligent, multichannel campaigns.

Two companies competing in the space are Dealerwing and PureCars. While both claim to deliver results for automotive marketing, their strategies and offerings diverge significantly — especially when it comes to fixed ops performance. Dealerwing is purpose-built for service marketing, while PureCars primarily focuses on digital advertising with a heavy lean toward vehicle sales.

In this article, we’ll compare Dealerwing vs. PureCars and explain why more dealers are turning to Dealerwing for ROI-driven, multichannel automotive service marketing that includes direct mail, email, and SMS text messaging.

 

---

1. Fixed Ops Focus: Dealerwing Specializes Where PureCars Skims

Let’s be clear: PureCars is a strong player in digital advertising for automotive sales. Its platform helps dealers run paid search, display, and social campaigns that attract vehicle shoppers.
But when it comes to service marketing, PureCars is not a true specialist. Its offerings do not include service-specific campaigns powered by lifecycle data, nor does it deliver messaging through direct mail, email, or SMS — channels that dominate service engagement and retention.

Dealerwing, on the other hand, is purpose-built for fixed ops marketing. Every tool, strategy, and campaign is designed to:

• Increase service appointments
• Boost RO value
• Win back lapsed customers
• Retain loyal service clients
• Target conquest opportunities through localized outreach

That’s not an afterthought — it’s the core mission.

---

2. Multichannel Execution: Dealerwing Covers All the Right Channels

A one-channel strategy is a missed opportunity in today’s service landscape. Service customers expect communication on their terms — via email, mobile, and even traditional direct mail. PureCars focuses exclusively on digital ads (search, social, display), which may work for sales but often fall flat in fixed ops.

Dealerwing delivers multichannel engagement through:

Automotive Direct Mail

• VIN-targeted service offers
• Personalized by name, vehicle, and last RO
• QR codes and promo codes for tracking
• First-class delivery for urgency

Automotive Email Marketing

• Triggered campaigns tied to service intervals (30K/60K/90K)
• Lapsed customer reactivation emails
• Loyalty reward offers and recall notices
• A/B tested for performance

SMS Text Messaging

• High-response reminders and offers
• Mobile booking links
• Time-sensitive campaigns (e.g., “Last Day to Save!”)
• Full opt-in compliance

With PureCars, none of these critical channels are natively included — making Dealerwing the only real omnichannel solution for service marketing.

---

3. Data-Driven Targeting: AI vs. Ad Audiences

PureCars uses digital ad platforms’ targeting options (Google, Meta, etc.) for segmentation — helpful for vehicle shoppers but not specific to vehicle service needs. Dealerwing uses AI for car dealerships to create real-time audience curation based on:

• Service history and RO data
• VIN, mileage, and maintenance cycles
• Engagement scoring from past campaigns
• Loyalty and customer value tiers
• DMS integration and CRM behavior

This ensures your service offers go to the right person at the right time — not just a demographic guess or a geo-targeted ad.

---

4. Offer Personalization and Campaign Flexibility

PureCars’ creative is designed for high-volume, standardized sales ads. Offer personalization is limited, and service campaigns — if available — often lack nuance, seasonal relevance, or geographic specificity.

Dealerwing gives service marketers full control:

• Launch winter tire specials in snowy ZIP codes
• Promote brakes to high-mileage vehicles
• Send loyalty offers to customers with 3+ visits
• Test different headlines, discounts, and formats

Whether it’s a lapsed customer campaign, a seasonal push, or a conquest offer, Dealerwing empowers you to pivot fast and target with precision.

---

5. Transparent ROI & RO-Level Attribution

Digital ad platforms (like those PureCars uses) report on impressions, clicks, CPC, and CTR — but not on R.O.-level attribution or actual service revenue generated.

Dealerwing tracks:

• RO matchbacks from every mailer, email, and SMS
• Appointment-to-RO conversions
• Revenue generated per campaign and per channel
• Cost per appointment
• Campaign-level ROI and lifetime value impact

That means you’re not just guessing which channel worked — you see exactly what booked, serviced, and paid.

---

6. Service Retention vs. Sales Focus

PureCars does an excellent job helping dealerships move metal. But once the sale is complete, their platform largely moves on to the next shopper. There’s limited emphasis on post-sale retention or service relationship-building.

Dealerwing is designed to:

• Keep customers coming back
• Increase frequency of service visits
• Reactivate dormant customers
• Nurture loyalty through personalized follow-up

From welcome series to win-back campaigns, Dealerwing ensures the customer journey doesn’t end after the sale — it begins.

---

Real-World Example: Dealerwing in Action

Objective: Reactivate customers who hadn’t serviced in 12+ months.

Campaign Tactics:
AI segmented 1,300 lapsed customers with VINs over 50K miles
Personalized direct mail with $60 off 60K-mile maintenance
Triggered email sequence with service checklist and reminder
Final SMS sent 24 hours before expiration

Results:
19.3% response rate
Over $78,000 in service revenue
8.7x campaign ROI
29% of responders booked a follow-up within 90 days
This kind of precision and multichannel coordination isn’t available in PureCars’ ad-focused platform.

---

Dealerwing vs. PureCars: Which One Is Right for Your Service Marketing?

---

Final Thoughts: Choose the Right Partner for Fixed Ops Performance

If you want to sell more cars, PureCars is a solid digital ad platform.

If you want to grow service revenue, retain more customers, and create a scalable fixed ops marketing machine, Dealerwing is the clear winner.
With:

• Personalized direct mail, email, and SMS
• AI-powered audience curation
• Transparent RO-based reporting
• Campaign flexibility dealers control
• Purpose-built service marketing strategies

Dealerwing delivers the complete package for dealerships serious about fixed ops success.

Ready to Build Your Best-Performing Service Campaigns?

At Dealerwing, we help dealerships like yours increase service appointments, win back lapsed customers, and grow retention with smarter, faster, and more measurable marketing.

Let’s fill your bays with campaigns that work. Contact Dealerwing today.